woman-physician-reading-x-ray-diagnostics-for-a-pa-2026-01-11-10-58-47-utc (1)

The High Cost of “Over-Diagnosis”: Why Your Dental Estimate Might Be More Fiction Than Fact

In our corner of the East Valley, we pride ourselves on community and trust. Whether we’re meeting neighbors at the Queen Creek Olive Mill or seeing families at Mansel Carter Oasis Park, there’s an unspoken rule: we look out for one another.

As a dentist at It’s Your Time Dental, our office is driven by a philosophy we call “Gentle Excellence.” One of our core values is to be Ethical. Lately, however, I’ve been seeing something in my office that demonstrates that some other offices are either unethical or ignorant.

Patients are coming to me for second opinions, clutching treatment plans for thousands of dollars from other offices. When I sit down with these patients and do an often cursorary exam, I find a startling reality: much of the “urgent” work they were told they needed isn’t necessary at all.

Most of the time this isn’t just a difference of professional opinion but a systemic issue of over-diagnosis. Today, I want to pull back the curtain on the “bogus” treatments I’m seeing most often and explain how you can protect your health and your pocketbook.

1. The “Automatic” Build-Up: A Hidden Tax on Crowns

One of the most common line items I see on inflated dental estimates is the “core build-up” on every diagnosed crown. By definition, a build-up is a foundational restoration needed when a tooth needs a crown but has so much missing tooth structure that structure needs to be replaced so the crown has something to “grab” onto.

Think of it like a contractor telling you that every time they paint a room, they also have to replace the drywall. In reality, if the tooth is mostly intact, a build-up isn’t needed. At It’s Your Time Dental, we only perform a build-up when it is structurally required for the longevity of the tooth. Charging for one automatically is essentially a hidden tax on the patient, adding hundreds of dollars to a procedure that should be straightforward.

2. Root Canals on Vital/Live Teeth: The “Ghost” Infection

Perhaps the most alarming trend is the recommendation of root canals on teeth that are still alive and often perfectly healthy.

In our office, we know that root canal therapy is a great way to preserve a tooth but also understand that a vital tooth is much better than a non-vital one. We do thorough testing to figure out if the tooth is still alive and healthy enough to survive treatment before condemning it to root canal therapy. Many teeth are sensitive to cold due to root exposure, decay or wear. When a tooth is sensitive to cold, we know it is alive. That does not mean it needs root canal therapy. We use vitality tests, x-ray, and percussion testing to determine the health of the tooth. If a tooth responds normally to cold and doesn’t hurt when tapped (percussion), that nerve is healthy. It is “vital.” Yet, I’ve seen patients scheduled for root therapy because a dentist saw a deep shadow or can’t figure out why a tooth is sensitive.

Root canal therapy is a procedure that removes the living tissue from inside your tooth. It should be a last resort to save a tooth from infection or unbearable pain—not a “precautionary” measure to pad a bill. If you’re being told you need a root canal but you have no pain or only occasional pain make sure other options are investigated prior to jumping to root canal therapy.

3. The “Deep Cleaning” Trap

We’ve all been there—life gets busy, and you realize it’s been a year (or two) since your last dental cleaning. When you finally make it into an office, you expect a standard cleaning. Instead, you’re told you have “advanced gum disease” and need a multi-thousand-dollar “Deep Cleaning” (Scaling and Root Planing).

While periodontal disease is a serious medical condition that we treat aggressively when present, the length of time since your last cleaning does not automatically dictate the type of cleaning you need.

I’ve seen patients with perfectly healthy pink gums being told they need “Deep Cleanings” simply because they haven’t been to a dentist in a while. At our practice, we measure your “pockets” (the depth of the space between your tooth and gum) and use our scanners, x-rays, and AI assisted x-ray analysis to show you the actual state of your oral health. If there’s no bone loss and no deep pockets, you don’t need a deep cleaning. You just need a thorough, gentle standard cleaning.

Even if we see bone loss, build up on the teeth, and irritated, bleeding, or puffy gums, that doesn’t tell the whole story. In almost every case we will do an initial cleaning to evaluate the actual effort needed to clean your teeth. If you are too tender, the build up is too tenacious, or the condition of your gums requires anesthesia/numbing for you to be comfortable while they are cleaned, we will recommend “deep cleanings”.

4. The Illusion of Urgency: The “Sears Tower” Close

High-pressure sales tactics belong at a used car lot, not a doctor’s office. I often hear from patients who were told, “If you don’t get this treatment done today, you will lose the tooth.”

While dental issues do progress, very few things in dentistry (outside of an active infection or a broken front tooth) are “same-day” emergencies. If an office is pressuring you to sign a financing agreement before you’ve even had time to process the diagnosis, they aren’t respecting your time—they’re respecting their own bottom line.

5. Cosmetic “Needs” vs. Cosmetic “Wants”

We love helping Queen Creek residents achieve the smiles of their dreams. Whether it’s hidden fillings, Invisalign, crowns, implants, or veneers, cosmetic dentistry can change a person’s life.

However, there is a clear ethical line between offering a cosmetic improvement and diagnosing it as a medical necessity. If a dentist tells you that you “need” veneers to save your teeth, but your teeth are functionally sound, they are misrepresenting the treatment. At It’s Your Time Dental, we believe in honest conversations. If you want to improve your smile, we’ll show you the best ways to do it. But we will never tell you that a cosmetic choice is a medical requirement.

6. The “Filling vs. Crown” Debate: Respecting Your Pocketbook

This is the heart of the “over-diagnosis” problem. A crown is significantly more expensive than a filling. It also requires removing more of your natural tooth structure.

I cannot tell you how many times I’ve looked at a patient’s “Needs Crown” estimate and realized I could fix the problem with a conservative, high-quality composite filling.

Why does this happen? Crowns are more profitable and often easier for the dentist. But our core value of Generosity means we want to give more than expected—and often, what’s “more” is actually “less” invasive. If a filling will work and be expected to last a reasonable amount of time, that is what we’ll recommend. We want to preserve your natural tooth as long as possible. Once you cut a tooth down for a crown, you can never go back.

The Power of the Second Opinion: Why It Should Be Free

You might wonder why we offer second opinions for free. It’s because we believe that once you see the truth on a screen, the choice becomes easy.

In the old days, you had to trust the dentist’s word because you couldn’t see what they saw. Today, we use high-tech intraoral scanners. These aren’t just X-rays; they are high-definition, 3D digital maps of your mouth.

When I perform a second opinion, I invite the patient to look at the screen with me.

  • “See that dark spot? That’s why you need a filling.”
  • “This old silver filling isn’t pretty but there are no signs of it failing”.
  • “You can see here where AI helps shows where you need to concentrate more to prevent this getting any bigger/worse”.
  • “See how this nerve looks healthy and there’s no shadow here? That’s why you don’t need a root canal.”

When you can see your own teeth in 4K resolution, the “mystery” of dentistry disappears. You aren’t just taking my word for it—you’re seeing the evidence for yourself.

Respecting Your Time, Your Health, and Your Community

At It’s Your Time Dental, our name isn’t just a slogan. It’s a promise. We know you have a choice in where you take your family for care. We know that your time is valuable and your trust is hard-earned.

If you have walked out of a dental office feeling overwhelmed, confused, or “sold to,” I encourage you to come see us. Bring your estimate. We won’t judge you, and we won’t bash the other office. We will simply evaluate what you were told and take the necessary steps to give you the honest, conservative truth. Once you have our opinion you can then use the information as you would like. If we agree with the diagnosis and plan and you want to go back to the other dental office, as long as you are happy there, we are fine with that. You will be going back knowing you are thoroughly informed about your decisions concerning your oral health.

Queen Creek deserves a higher standard of dental ethics. We are here to provide it, one honest smile at a time.

Red Flags to Watch For:

  • The “One-Day” Estimate: If they won’t let you leave without signing a contract.
  • The “Package Deal”: If every tooth suddenly needs the exact same expensive treatment.
  • The “Invisible” Problem: If the dentist can’t show you the problem on a clear photo or scan.
  • The “Silent” Exam: If the dentist spends 30 seconds in your mouth and a “coordinator” spends 30 minutes talking about money.

It’s Your Time Dental Located in the heart of Queen Creek 21295 S Ellsworth Loop Rd, Suite 103 Queen Creek, AZ 85142 (480) 445-9188 www.itsyourtimedental.com

Share this post